S R O 9 _ N 6 Q N 3 7 S 6 S 0 ! ̂ M Q 3 M 1 4 b Q " U Q < 2 Q̂ 4 Q 8 M 4 O > # 3 Q 3 4 J 4 $ K 4 M < W 5 N 9 L % R X 6 2 O & Q U S B N U [ M 5 ' Q ( S 2 N 6 ' O S ) @ 7 \ [ ? W P * 2 8 Q R 8 R QO + QO F 9 Q * S S 2 P [ : 8 S , k : 4 S S W S Q ? 2 % N Q -9 S 6 S ] S O Q [ N ; N 4 3 O T c 4 P . . 3 < O < 1 M N % _ l Q 1 2 P S Q = N / C P O O S 3 3 4 S 6 M O Q 9 N P 3 S d 4 U U QS Q < 3 [ Q V 8 ; M 3 > R < O 3 P 2 ? S S [ 4 ] @ O A G S _ ? Q̂ 2 [ W B e M [ N 3 5 9 S S ; ; S 9 N C X < Z R 3 P P 2 ? Q [ P M D 6 N ] 2 H ; [ ? S I H Y < Q : I S 1 S Z E [ 2 [ M 2 S G Q 6 S A M 2 \ Q < O N N 5 e l O 9 Q : 5 O 6
=
SSOS n P ̂ QN P l Q R P W R Q Q O n n P n P P S[ U o P S W PNURQM M
: ; Q 9 R 7 P ; Q < 2 X S Ô 3 U E ? F O N W 6 ? 2 [ U J D 6 M K P 2 N < 8 4 J R < K 2 N > B S m [ Q < G O 3 M ? M 2 R P S 6 7 Q S 5 Q f N B a g < O 3 h ? i 6 i j O N N HI S Y O W < S 1 ] 2 S Q P O NO S
t u
_ E v Y : ! - ;? $ . > Y . E # % p 2 * 6 % , < /% ' 9 w q 6 7 * b ! 4 r 4 % 3 s 4< ' 9 ( 6 / B ! 2 ') @? * 8F284?64c3<1C349d3;3<324G2e5;9<3?6HI<12G2e5;9<3?6JK42B<3?6
-
= 1 " 3 0 E -# E ; / E 0 / 7 $ 0 0 % 1 ; & F < / 2 0 3 / & 2 3 D 4 D 7 ' 7 0 G / ( 2 7 6 5 2 ) . * 0 3 7 5 0 +! 9 6 , 2 . 0 / ; 6 7 / 1 0 0 2 6 2 ; 7 7 7 8 / 2 > /2 ; 7 0 3 . 0 8 H / / 2 0 . 1 7 ? 9 2 . /7 C3 / 2 . /2 / I 7 @ > A ? B 0 0 2 ; 9 / J 7 05 /0 ; 5 ; /23C K 8 0 0 / 2 0 / 1 2 F L / / 7 . 2 / 2 0 3 2 9
= = ! .
=
P J D 0 C 0 9 3 5 F 3 -D 7 . D 0 . 6 G / 7 C3 6 ; 3 5 G 6 2 J 2 0 3 . 8 0 6 2 7 3 2 2 . ; N 7 7 K ; 2 / 2 / 0 / / 0 2 D ; 2 / 2 7 . ; 2 F < 7 D D 0 . ; / H 3 0 7 2 0 / D / 7 ; / 3 2 0 ; 6 2. 2 C . 3 9 / 2 J 2 6 8 ; 5 H 7 3 2 . 7 5 M 3 7 2 / 2 0 / 7 H C 1 3 3 2 0 . 7 2 2 7 . 2 0 6 ; C 3 3 I 0 1 M 3 0 / 5 0 0 3 3 1 2 0 6 7 / 2 / 7 3 ; 0 . H 2 / 9 ; 9 2 / / 0 3 ; J 2 0 8 / 2 0 3 7 2. . / H 2 8 /0 / 2 ; 2 . 7 3 D
= 2 a eQ 2 RX 5 P̀ 3 ]̂ X Q . Q R O / R̂ ]̂ P̀ 0 S 3 / d T 7 ] ] D W Y P U 2 1 R V 7 X . Z D W Q [ 5 X V R C b 2 a X 3 . P S D T V V W . 2 Q Y m ]̂ / Y X Z _ [ Z X [ 2 o m 9 P̀ k / V 0 a K \ l V T R Q D V c g ]P P D h ]̂ R i Q 5 _ / [ 3 C 3 W P R P̀ N . 9 R 3 ] ] e P W W ] H U 3 c V U V ] 8 P X Y / V n 8 7 ] / P Q 0 U W / 1 2 a Y . Z . [ S G Z X [ V X 7 5 Q P D R V \ 7 8 b 7 R U U 7 b 7 Q 9 m c / d 1 d ; ]̂ K . 6 R R 7 2 _ D 5 j e 2 ; 3 \ ]̂ 8 d̂ C 3 ] _ P̀ / R 2 / / 0 . 1 \ ] W 1 C . j / U 0 2 P̀ V Q R a 1 @ 3 V _ 7 7 / V 2 X V 5 7 1 3 Y B b / 9 ]̂ U 7 2 Z / P̀ 8 [ 0 -] 0 X W . 3 3 P / R̂ / Q 2 8 7 Q m D V /7 8 c f _ R 1 S V S 7 V / 7 P 0 2 U W a ]̂ 8 1 P / 0 ]̂ 0 / _ ; 2 1 . _ V 7 3 Uj P̀ 2 / 2 X V / 7 V
: . 5 4
-2 j I @ 0 V -. 3 b / 7 / j 0 . n / 7 2 ; 3 V 5 A j / Q 7 j . \ 0 3 . V 2 3 0 R / 0 2 U 7 7 / 1 b̂ Q 3 C d C 0 8 3 3 / P 2 ]W / 3 [ 2 W 0 K 2 ; . c . 2 2 a R̂ 3 B k 7 R D c e p q C P S 2 H / R 3 W ]̂ 3 Q 0 0 0 / ; V̂ 5 5 ; _ 7 7 0 9 \ C b ] W 1 P̀ d ]̂ b 9 _ cP Z W b [X Q b̂ R R̂ Ŝ a U a P m Q] b̂ b T W Ŝ d a ]̂ b P̀ _ U V Q e V R g j Q h R i Q V PW P̀ Uj Y V Z b̂ [ X X a ]̂ QV P̀ ]W b P V U Q m m Ub b Q U V _ R V V a \ b ]̂ W X _ o R b Ŝ Q] V V U P W j R ]̂ \ e ]P̀ 0 0 0 2 3 2 2 3 7 8 / 3 3 2/ 7 8 3 7 < 0 5 0 5 7 / 2 8 0 ; 2 7 7 9 ; / r 7 7 5 0 5 3 2 3 . 0 7 0 2 2 / ; 7 3 0 3 7 2 ; 2 6 / 0 . G 2 ; /0 . 7 2 8 ; 7 . . L / 5 . 0 2 / . 7 D 7 / 8 2 D 1 /0 0 / 1 / 1 G C/ . 6 5 2 7 9 0 2 2 3
45"! , 1 / ! 0 % , " " # 1 $ " 1 " 0 " " " , % 1 " , ( " % , & " 6 ! % ! " ! 2 % 3 ( ! " # 1 1 % " % " ' 7 & ( ! " 8 % , " 7 )* +, (, % ! & 1 - " , % % ".
Y,( 4 T 7 < 1 = % % ? " ! ( " G ! N , 9 1 , > % ! B ! 9 " > , 1 - < = 1 0 A " D 1 ! , B 0 # % E ; 8" @ F : = F ; > B G > @ ; ( B = , " = A % ; 6 < C B ! <= > U 1 H > M A < % < D ? O @ B ! < " A = " B E , @ C 0 F % G A F ( @ D , B F B G F @ E G < = F ? A @ F 6 A C " B < H G M 1 = @ B = V " > A N ! @ B D A C B @ A > C -W G H P H 2 @ M C = A " , N I 8 @ J " M X Q GK R C S 7 L D & < GB ! ; A % D " ! " B 8 # , 0 > ! H " ?A H M6 C GB A B % M "
U
T % 9 % " X 0 ; ! ! ,
% ;" %"! "1 !," (,8%," %3" " 1 !3!
$ 2 T Y 1 - 1 % " % ( ( 1 4 4 4 4 U ! " " ! ! a % ! , , ! ( % % " 0 % ( X 7 8 % % ! ! U " ! ( 0 1 " _ ! , , 1 ; ! % , -% ! / 1 8 ! ! 1 ! / % " ! " 1 " , % 3 1 , 0 , 3 % 8 ! 2 % , ! , " , % , Y " " 1 ( ! , % [ ( 8, ! [ Z " \ % ] , U " ̂ % 8 " , b % " , 1 # - " 5 1 % 0 % % " 1 ( ! % & " # ! 8 , X 0 ( ! ! ( " ! 1 " , " 1 " % 8 , , % , , 1 ( % " % , " " 8 ) 2 " 2 , . U / , - 8 % 1 % % 1 " 1 3 ! % 8 " ( 0 0 , , 1 2 % " ! 1 , ( " ! ! 0 , ! " 7 ! ! " 2 ( % , " % 3 " , " ! 8 % 1 " 1 1 , , !! 0 8 ! " ! [ " , " ! % % " " 1 Y ; 7 % ! ( ( ( , ! % , ( " " ! 0 " % ; 1 1 # # " , " , ( " , " , % % ! 1
/
C
!
/
3 0 0 " 12 # 2 $ 4 6 % 3 & 60 4 ' ( ? ) ' * ( ! 12 5 4 0 ) 6 & 6 5 + 0 , 2 & 6 -0 .' . 2 ( 7 3 ) 4 14 12 6 8 6 ? 6 3 0 8 2 9 : ; 3 < < 3 6 4 = 2 1= 8 6 0 61 3 4 @ > 1 = < 4 12 < 13 4 3 5 5 0 1 < 2 0 = 4 1 2 = 34 6 0 H DD
; < 5 6 E . 6 0 ) 1 1 3 . & < 4 ' + 2 " < F 6 6 ! 6 1 I 0 3 3 ) = 4 " 6 6 4 1 0 0 ( = 3 4 8 ' ( A 6 . 2 0 / ' 6 " 2 0 . 1 . 6 ( 2 " 1 . ) = ( 6 1< 3 3 ) 4 2 < 6 6 6 4 3 0 B 6 2 B 6 0 16 G 0 2 1 2 < 4 J 0 3 E 3 6 @ 1 2 1 2 1 4 6 1 4 F 0 3 2 < 1 4 6 4 0 6 = F 1 4 0 5 0 1 F 4 2 < 0 = 1 0 6 3 = 2 2 6 2 4 26 K 4 6 4 = 6 6 3 4 3 1 < 1 4 E = 2 A3 = 2 3 2 1 A 1 2 2 6 6 0 2 6 4 1 0 3 < 4 1 4 2 6 2 6 5 5 1 4 A 1 2 3 F 6 0 0 4 6 3 B 3 4 @ F 1 2 = = 2 12 B 6 = 0 / 6 0 13 6 1 8 2 4 0 0 4 2 = E = 6 3 1< 1 4 2 @ 6
= 0 F 4 3 ) 1 P P P P & 1 < 4 + 2 % 6 ? ? ? 2 ? 1 < & 3 1 < = 3 @ 4 @ 1 F 6
3
1 1 = <3 6 P ' 3 1 2 < ( < B A ) 1 6 2 8 M 4 1 1 6 ' 4 Q = N F 1 5 < 3 R 1 B 6 2 4 A 4 2 6 1 3 8 F 3 Q 6 2 0 A 1 B 3 3 6 O Q / 4 3 3 0 =1 2 6 = 3 K 2 6 1< 6 1 5 1 2 < K 0 1 6 6 1 0 4 F < 6 3 < 4 3 A = 1 @ 6 4 1 6 2 6 1 1 4F 4 4 6 F 8 4 A 1 0 4 3 6 = 6 L 2 6 3 0 6 4 0 4 3 ? 6 A 0 6 0 6 0 4 < 6 34 0 4 = E 6 1 2 6 1 6 3 1 3 4 4 2 2 < 2 6 0 @ 6 1 2 < 4 2 1 2 6 A 0 1 < 3 = 1 6 6 1 1 < 4 6 6 0 5 4 6 4 1F 6 3 0 6 = 3 A3 2 2 /0 P P S426<3421=50606071412685223414=61414F6066046 P 1 4 @ 61 4 ? ? ? ? 1 4 1= 6 F @ 0 1 F 3 A 6 3 A 2 6 8 1 0 4 Q = < 71412 3 6 6 8 2 6 6 60 R 1 O < 6 2 2 1 8 3 @ F Q 2 A 1 2 < Q 3 3 6 4 4 = K = A 6 1 1 < < 1 E 6 61 3 1 4 6 1 3 45 < 1 61 1 4 @ F A 6 0 3 ? = 1< 4 6 B / < 3 616 1 1 < 3 3 4 @ 5 1 = K 4 1F 6 0 0 1 6 2 2 2 3 2 2 5 < 6 0 1 6 1 1 3 4 4 6 K6 3 0
= < 6 2 0 36 64=
6 1 6 26 0 4 62 ?4663@46<16
I J 2 ! # 3 ) $ 4 # ! 0 # ) ! 5 $ " # " " 6 $ 6 ! , 0 , ) 4 % " 7 & , " 8 , # ' 9 $ 2 ! : ; ) ! , # < $ ( ! = $ $ # ! ! > ! ! ) $ K 2 ! = 0 ! " " # ? ( # * , $ < $ ) ' = + # " 0 " 4 , 1 -" ; ! ) $ ! 9 ! $ " =
!
# G " 0 2 ! $ 8 ' " $ 0 $ , < ! < ! " - ! ? # ( , " 4 " # $ ; ! $ ) 0 ; " , 2 ! / 3 ! K . ) # 4 $ $ ( "$ 7 ! 0 4 " 9 H " , , , ! " @ , 2 " 3 " + $ " ) " , = ! ! - A ! ( -# 2 " ! B " , C " , # , , " $ 4 " # H , $ / ! A ! ) = "0 $ " " ? # $ D ( # 0 3 ' " $ B > 1 # ! 3 ) " ! / ! 2 " " " 3 ! # " " $ 4 $ " # $ $ ( $ 5 + # ! # 6 6 0 , , 4 ! 7 ! ! " 8 # # 9 $ $ 2 (" ? " $ 4 # E $ / F H ! ! " B ) 0 ? ) ( 4 # ! ; 0 ! ! ) 2 ) 3 -4
Q 8
1 3 66 J $ # !) 4 ( ! N N N N 7B # / R > 8 8 ! $ : !) 9 9 " $ 4 " 2 0 , , 7 + ; ( 9 ! + 9 / = " - # 4 # 2 ( -4 4 K # O ; < $ , " $ # 2 $ ! 0 A 3 = ! , P $ " " 4 , ? $ " # , ( ( 5 - ! # # O L , 6 ( 6 ! # O 4 ) 0 / # 7 ! " 8 " # K (# # 9 " $ $ 2
( G b Z $ ) " $ 4 [ $ / 0 @ \ "
N " 8 + ]̂ " G $ ? + < _̀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a @ + ! / # [ $ " , \ D - . ! , . ! K $ + 3 H ! ! " " ) $ " 4 # $ " , $ " 2 ! " , , , 3 P ! 4 ! , ! * ! " " -- ? $ # -! " $ 2 K # H H , 3 # $ , $ # 4 $ 0 " , ! $ , $ , , , c H " ( ( " ! # 0 # ) # B 9 , -, " , , B $ 0 ; $ # # , 2 0 " ! " $ ! $ " ? " # d ) , # ! 0 " : $ " ; " # , e * 0 , , $ ! ! K " " ! $ $ # # H 0 # $ " , ( ( $ " " " $ # $ , , , ' " 0 -, " $ 0 0 0 / " " $ ! $ # ) " , # + + $ ( $ / ! ( ! ! " ! ! ! ) # 0 ) ) "# ! / $ " $ # " ( 0 ! " ! ! 0 " ! , $ " $ " e $ $ # # ! , , ( # ! " 0 H $ " ( , ( " # $ " # # $ " " 0 , $ + " ! + # ) " K H ) $ " ! 0 ! ! $ # ! ) 0 " + ! , $ # " 0 " ! # $ / , ! G $ + ) " $ , 0 - H ( - ! $ ! 0 ) $ # ! ) , " ) # " ! $ $ ' ! H , X ' !) , # $ , / ! 0 ! # " ) ) # " $ + / $ $ , " ! " ( + 0 ) # ! ! ' $ ) ( G ! 0 # 1 " # # H # ) ! ! $ # " " Y ! $ " # ! , # + # ( $ $ ! + ) ! ( ) " K ' -K
!"
;9;< % # 789: = & $ >
U ' R ? H ( @ ) I 8 J * J A U & K A ? % B + M C L Q + B = N 9 M Y M Y [ O M P O N R , D O Z M M Z N N O M P O P L R P M @ -N [ P E \ -L W O < . Y -: M 9 + F Q P 9 B R : U / C R T % S M N O 0 MT P ) M 1 O M M ' P N Q % R 1 P S - O M M O T ) P M M O R P N - N 2 W O . + R 3 L , . - T O 4 N L . P ( M U .+ R . % O - OM O 1 P P % G R N 5 W V 6 ( X MU R + N .) PL OPRR Y Y Y M P M M M T W M Z S L Z M O M Z Z W N M O P S P M O M P N P L M \ R N W N P M R P M O P R L R N N L X N N O P M T N O PM R P R N W R P W P U M R O P P L M R R T N P O P R O R T N M N MN P M P N P M T L PX N U R U W N R T W N M U M R Q MW N O M M P N [LR T O \ W R S S MR Q U X M P O M N W R N̂ P T \ O MO U R Q R U X \ O X T R M W T M P P Q P M NP N ] P _ PRSNPWMPMW[M\LP
Part G – Order The panel decision is: (Check one)
APPEAL NUMBER 2024 - 0081
☒Unanimous ☐By Majority
The Panel ☒Confirms the Ministry Decision ☐Rescinds the Ministry Decision If the ministry decision is rescinded, is the panel decision referred back to the Minister for a decision as to amount? Yes☐ No☐ Legislative Authority for the Decision: Employment and Assistance Act Section 24(1)(a)☒ or Section 24(1)(b) ☐ Section 24(2)(a)☒ or Section 24(2)(b) ☐
Part H – Signatures
Print Name Corrie Campbell
Signature of Chair
Date (Year/Month/Day) 2024/04/10
Print Name Glenn Prior
Signature of Member Print Name Kenneth Smith
Signature of Member
EAAT003 (30/08/23)
Date (Year/Month/Day) 2024/04/10
Date (Year/Month/Day) 2024/04/10
Signature Page