Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction

Decision Information

Decision Content

 ! "#$#%&''(

I     

) * +,-,.//*  ,-0)  +./-,* 0,./* +,-,./.10) 2,/,-03.14.+,5 6 .  /0 /*7.6 038 *+0,./0) ,/,-03 *0 *9/3 : :;),+)) *0)00)  /0<=  > -01.+,-,--   /01.).  ,-*. -/.0 0 >, *0) +,0 ,- 0.0,/ - +0,./?@.10)  .3 /0/*--,-0/+ 1.7 -./-;,0)5,-,,0, -8 A0,./0) 8 A0,./ B) ,/,-03;--0,-1, *0)00)  /0)-/. -.+ -0. ,0) 1..-/*;-:).; 6 :,0;-/.0-0,-1, *0)0

CDEFGHHFIGJD<=JFFKLMNNFHGONMLLIMMN=GJKPGI=,-* 0./ Q +0 *+,+-0/+ -R /*0)0

CDEFGHHFIGJD<=EFGIDEPOISFOJOTTOJFJDKGJUFNOLEFKMF=JMDNFHGONDEF*A -B

V(W#XY !( "#

 .3 /0/*--,-0/+ 1.7 -./-;,0)5,-,,0, -8 A0,./ZDEF[\FU]IGDOMĴ_:- +0,./?@

),-- +0,./.10)  A,-0,./+/ 1./*00) /*.10) * +,-,./B

abccd"ef!

 



I    

 !""#"  $%"&$ '" 

()*+,-,.*/0,1 2+ -*,..)3, ,-*)04,.,,*/..,.*-35

6-)7 8  *+ -*3) *40)0)3,.,.. -*0)+) ,.5 9:)*1 2;<=>?@>AB:.)3C4,-/C,*3+--4*+))8-4*+0))-4:.: D>E>ABD?@FGEBHI>JBFKL 2+.*,*43).*0)*+ ,.,.M 5 2N+- ) *4:+*+*+.,**,)-*+*4*)+,.O.*:.-P 3*48+ .3*4;-)L5 2QRB@>FSBDTRBURB=URB=B?F>@?EE?@B@UD>@AB=UGR?FHRVF?J>IRB>IURRBT=GUBW;X :)4,7,-Y,-*+JGIDZT?URG[URB>U\>@DT?URG[U]>F?JRVA?B@BKL

-̂*4*4)7_8  *+ -* )*48,- *1 2+CY)0*+3,,-Y-4:..**4,-. ,-Y  5*.**4)-*+:.8:,*+ .)4 -..)-*+0))-43,,-Y80)):4/.)-*)0,-:* . ,-Y,-53C.-4Y.Y-*)Y4/ -4P -44,-.-4 *-  5 29,.4,.4.-,)-43--))-Y )/45 2à9/4).-*.))-*)3+3C)--Y/.7,-Y.-4.:*+**+0-3:.*-4 )0-4*+))* *:. b̀5 2,0)()*,.à.+):.*+*+,.+).,.-)*+*44*)33C4:.5 29-4. )*3*,)-0)*+:,-*3)45 2c?FJ[==B@URG[F?@AJG@D?U?G@?F@GIG@AB=F[d?J?B@UUGE>?@U>?@R?F;]>F?JI?dB>@D RVA?B@BLK

-̂+,.O.*0)3)-.,4*,)-4*4e-/ 8 *+ -*:)*1 2;X@BBDUR?F=BH>?=UGH=GUBJUEVRB>IUR>@Df[>I?UVGdI?dBW>@DBgB@HGFF?]IV?@JGID 3,*.0),-Y0).*,*-Zd=BBh?@AUGDB>UR\KL

N,*++,.O.*.0)3)-.,4*,)-*+ -*.,*43) /)0+,.()*,.à,-4 ,3*.)033C4:.84Y43,,-Y-40))8.,-C.-4Y*)8.:,*3+*+*,. ?@;GdLHGF?U?G@>@DF>VF;d[=@>JBLW-4)0* *YY..+):,-Y* *.)0i8 5j -4 4Y..,.593)-*41 2;k?@JBURB=B?F@GRB>U?@AJR>=ABWURBUBEHB=>U[=BGdEV=GGE?F>IEGFUURBF>EB>FURB G[UF?DBUR?FT?@UB=K; 2;lRBS?UJRB@F?@Sm?FnJIGAABD>@DA=?@DB=@GUTG=S?@AKL

 

I       !"#$%&" %$'() * "" +!,$("$-,- .$( * /%(01 2,( !/#*#$-#"*%#$-'&*%"$*/#/3$*"($- )".01 +)$/"$")( &$() //%(&*"$(*%""#$/#"43#*01

5 67897:;<798=>975785<?8@ A986BC896<D ?8<87 79859B575696<D EF A986BCG<68 79<696H 7 ?88997<75<696H 7 EI 6:598JG7< G<68 79<6?88997<75<696JG7< EF

KLMNOPQRSTUVQO

5 67897:<79G<W :7:X6C I  FA?<7757 5 C8679675<67<WY ZEFZ[I6::<86<75D<7BB C678  <7:C7596987CF 596987C\"(/#"# $:<86<7679<6?5C97:9:6<7G<689:75896]<G]B896 75]97G5675BB85::986<7?<]96B1 6:9675?85<<75G79G 7<<7585W:7<56:<88<W876B75?59G5G8:75896]7<GG]1 F=G875 96987C:9:6<7G<689:758I," )*(3,"#$%!#$$$/+10

J6X6C ̂I  75 67 <D9::?97689889<6?55877:@ A:9:6<7_87889876GW<7596987C:96B??75875:B :9:6<7 <8575<9W757696B98]F798<6C9675G<:?967?5675 :<<7 78<798:< 87<<6: a>769B5775775G97G<8 b98:7<6c G7:1d89GeFb596987C6:87<G<689:<7575 <G886:75 <7G<FW75 <G88986<76c G7:I97:<86f7675<7G<986<7 6c G7:F;<5<8896:9D9:8I8578 <D9::C75B<D667:96B 8DG<:?756c G7:<GG6G8 F1 AW8Wg96B<87D96B7<:75965988 F 5797<W96B6c G7:986<7:796:C79F1 55<898<95<F598WG7<C6WG7: <:G7587596C<W 879G 68<675c79<?8?59G5G689C<?6< 6C75?96:I6:759679< ?88 <7:CW9c:?<<:6 68F5986 7C8 G7?675 9679<6:c79<?8?975<76C96879<6Fh56759679<?8:B:I G<:9W<<789:G6:9G7C67598:<<F A796Bc 6886<7G<D:C598G676W978FD69W75?8 9:I 75 67G6<6C:i8775<<7 759B5769B576:<?:96B75 :C7<6875969876::<Wb6<796B96:6B<W75G<:bF ! +/ *(& 33*$\"*#"$  $*,#!!#$$)"*(, G<97CF?<:C8B<I<675D696B<WX6C 75Ij75 67e8W:

 

I       !"!#!$%!&!"%%  !' ()*+,-(.)/0)123.4+)25670)1(65408497:;).1+2<<= > !% !%?!!@  AB%'"#!CD!'%%?!!% !!?!" !C!%CCD%%"B >!CD%!E'F   %%%?!!B >?!!@   AB#!"%!!! %?!"!% DC!"% !G#! % !# H!#!?!B%!?!!'!F !#% !!!?#  !B%?!% '!?!"%?!GCD ! B >?!!% I2;.52+.)J0)5089K/LMLN<O;+).-(,+12+30P+()-;+ D!%%!D D!"%!"! ! %%'"!!!C ' BQ%"#CD'%!%! CD"!  '-;+0::+40)-I2%!"!B

R!%%?!!%  ?! !#%#C!"!S >T!@  A  !% !C!%U%'%?# %'!% !!CDC%C!% % B U%'%D%!"% !'%% C%C!%!"B >T!E'F   !CD!UD!"% #!#!C%%C!D% C!%B >T!E'   H!#!!!U!"  !C!%% B

VW'  %  ?! !#%#C!"!S >T!E' X   U-;+0::+40)-I27+1(,04,4()(,,.)*(8720Y:;.)+,04Z(2(-0::.()-7+)-=*.8J0)5089 A  B >T!E'A  % C!%U%!!?#%! !#%!!!D!"C%% %%C!#%!B >!#%!!% W'  'UY;918.,.8-(2.)+[\=<].*58-;+8()*.870-(.)(2:8.Z(1+1< >T!% '! !W'   % C!%U%! !!!#%!#!B

%%!"% %#C!"S

 

I             !"   #!$  %&   '      ()% &   ** % &  '*   +  %&   $ % &  '  % &    # $  "   ,% &    #-   #./012  %  *    / '   ,$  $      3  #% & #  *  *#   %&        % &      % &   '   ,     '  #%  #   %'  !  # !"#% &"*"        "% &" "           *%  #"$" $-$   * "*$  % &   $"*    $"     $"*   # * 3*  " "    $ %  '*  $$   '      $ "% 4          $   4  5  * %&  "$ 3 $    $    *'  5 % 4   #    6  ' * "     %     789:;9;<8=  #% 6&  '     '  " "  #% & >?@ABC8?DE:9FEG?C?89:H<88IJJE89?BC8K

 #L       M FEHF;NE;9EC;CAH;J:EEGEC9BCO?@E9F;9?DEC9?O?E89FEC;GEBO9FE;PPE@;C9<8 @;CD@B:DKQFE;PPE@;C9<8GBC9F@H:EC9?CA@IDE8>;9E:R8E>;JED?8PB8;@RJ;:S;JE  ! #*!"   !    !#! "*%  #$#*%  # '   $# *  $   $  $ * %

 



I      !"#$%"#&$# '( )) ) * +'(,'&"'#%"" '(-./011/20!/103/'("4(',%"'%%&5&" %,"6%$&",7#89%%&5&"*

'%'("5(::("," %"(#, #&"%,#,"#(#;" ''(((< %,'$"%,#,':%#('(=("<"#&#%"&"">%,#,%%&5?%&*

,'(('''"5#$@A%$#"'#%

 %$'%,("""'%$#"'#% #;',,5" %"%,"'%'("5#% %, ""'%:'((#%5=',$#$%,$','(&#(#$"(","#" B/C-3B/011/02D0C-E3/-./10/2!3B/0BF-G./CC30C/3-3BF./011/20!/H3/G-0C3112//G-# '(* % "$#,'"("'('%$#"'#%(;',%& (%""#(&"'#% #$" #5%"%, (('("%&&"*

 

 !" #!"$%&' '!"

I    

()*+,,-*+./)+,011*02+,3)*/)*4/)*5+.+,/467,8*9+,+:./:8*.6/)*011*20./094+,+, ; <=>?@? A;B;;?<C; ?=DC=@EAD<F?B;;?<  AF=A?<?>=@ AF<F=<=A<=@FAF;=<F;?>=@ <=G

HF=A?<IJ ;=;?=;EFA=AK?>B@AF@=@ <=;==>?=@A<A;=C C ?EADFA;A;; <=GL<FA=A?<A;=@==@ <=MA;=@; <==? =<<N F=DN <;??=A<<A=<N F=DC<DDG<?=@FA=A?<A;=@= >A=??=A<=@A=?==@N <;BAD=?AA<<=D<O=?/)*011*20./7, @C;AF@=@G

P11*20./7,Q:,+/+:.

()*011*20./7,1:,+/+:.A;=@=@;@?DAOA>?FA;A;; <=>?@? A; F;@=;MA<=;?>;F=A?<IJGRA; ACF?<F<A;=@D<O=?@A; @=@?O@=?<CF?D= =;GR;>;>?=@F?DF;@A;@?A;A< DA; AGRA;@=@@;<?=<>F=DC=@AB=S=C=@F?DB=@A< LF=?<D?EB@<@A;D??FN=CF?DGT<BA<=@A;D?? = =D? ;=? UV=<AO@=KB@AF@@F?<;AD;<N F=DGT<W<C@A;@=@ ;>DD=?<<N F=DF?D;< GRDAD<?=M;=;;A;=<F>?=@A<A;=CA F;=@DODAD<?= ?;@=@A;S=@<GRDAD<?==<?<=@@=F;@ <DD=?;E?<CGE<A>=@B;BA<O??D AK=@ <=B?D?<CDX;==@ = ==?A<ADO;?=@=@A;@=@A;<?=<D<ODG

;?K=@;<A=CF?<DA=A?<?>@A;@?A; ??G?AE<D;F@F?<DA=A?<;K; FAC; ;<A?KA;A;SCG()*5+.+,/467,8*9+,+:.8+8.:/9:.,+8*4/)*,+.YZ2:9Y0[*,+./)*Y+/9)*.0.8+. =@=@??<D;@?D=@>? C>?;A<S A;G

\A<A;=C]?;A=A?<

@A<A;=C ?;A=A?<A;=@==@C<?=;=A;>AD=@=/)*011*20./7,<D>?@? A;A; D=?<N F=DFAF;=<F;K;=@S;==DA<=@; A<OK<D=@>?A;<??<O <N F=DG A=@?=?A<>?=A?<?EAD<FK=@A<A;=CA;;?<=?;=A;@=@= /)*011*20./7, @C;AF@=@BAA<AA<<=D<OA>@D?;<?= A=@>??;<D 302,_()*3:48+55+.*./a8*.:/*,0,*.,*?>O<FCK<D=@ <=@;<?= ?EADD<C EAD<F=?A<DAF=@A; @C;AF@=@B?DA<O<=D<OBA=@?==@M;=D  A;G@ <=N A<D=@=@D?;<?=@E@=K=;?A<DAF=D=@=@A;><FA; =<D?>G@>?K=@A<A;=CB;;=A;>AD=@==@ <=BA<?=A<D<O?>=@ F?DA>@=<;?<@A;><FG

 



I    

 !" #$## " %"#&  #"#'( )"#"  "*+, -./01234'( #  5""%%"&67789:;76<<=667>:?@A:=>B#%C$,D # %<67789:;76<<=667>:?@A:=>EFG8H:I;HJH:H6J?FFG:FH:KL8976M;@8@;?FG8NO H6?FG987;6@978P8@;?QFG8@:F86<:99=;P:F;6?<67FG8P7;>;>>J99=8H8?F;>RNNS<678:PG 987>6?;?FG8<:H;=KJ?;FTU """VW   %%"C* # #'(X

Y:?8=Z8P;>;6?

 %" CC""# %  X

 %"$5"#" C&%&"C [* #"X "  $5"#C   * #"X\* &%% % C 5" &C#C"$5"%CC[% 5"$$C5X]003̂_24̀131a/bcc/db41effghi2ff234&&  * #"####"C X %" 5"# j C C$%# C+5$X

 """"CC[& %"$5"##[$%[C* #"X "" 5"5"#* C #[$C* #" " [C%"%5 #"" "##"C["X  !C &C%"* #" CC[$ C" X\& C%#[$%[%$&"%# #""* #"Xk$"$[#[#C$C"$""C" "%"##["[X) &  %"%#5"##[$%[#[C* #"X   !5$" [& #%"b0bgfbdd24lh/1m//41a/2ii24/41_b4̀/̂131a/bcc/db41ef "n )"% , "%# " &" "#" C$X

 

I     

  !!"#$% &$$"'() *)+,-.))  +-/)  -) -)*) ,+ , 0 +*-,)) ,1- 2 3+*4+5)+,-)) + * ("$"$6+*) 7 *+4 -)+ --5.5)-4) 8-95) 4:, ;< --5.5)2  -) *,4 ,5) -4,4), *,= )  ++** *>-4+9) -4,4+/-, *+* ? *)> 5,-)5)) @-4,4 --5.A-52

B,-5*+,-C

D E$#  &$$"'('$!6# FG&"!&" $FHIJF"K  - 9+-4*)) &$$"'(#!$$#' !"$$6&E",  +*1* *,-.* ,) 4.) =+4 -5 -4 *,-  +5)+,-,9)  /+*)+,-+-) 5+5*)-5 *,9)  -)2= -),/)  -)9+-4*+* 9+- 4+9+5)*+))+,-> 4, *-,) ))  ?+ 45+) +,9* 5)+,-LM,9) 7 /)+,-2 &$$"'("!$#"$#!$$$5,-9+ 4>-4)  -)+*-,)*55 **9,- 2

NOPOQRSTUOVWXPRTWYS

Z[\PY][OSTRŜ_XXWXTRS̀OaYbcObXYSXdWTefWXRgWPWTWOXNOVhPRTWYS

ibWXWXXh\\PO[OST

 

 

I           ! "   ## $ #" " ! " #   #  # %       & " ! &    & " ! ! !!   &     "     "    #'!    "! #   &    (    !$  " #  #'    #"!!  )!'*!)+  " ",  "     ! !# " !("  " % #    ! , - "     ! !#   #$     ! " !+" ! )'    " $!  " ,  "     ! !##!'  "$. " #($/  ###!' &  ! !" ! 0 # "  #'  ##  ' &  ! ! " !  #   #1"  "'!   #   &  "#+" ! ' &  "#+" ! !     ! !!  "2,3        45 637$++   4#82# $' 9  &  #+" ! 5' &  #+" ! 5!     ! !!  "2,5 6# 82# $'

 " '##"  #'! " ##"$'   ! ! &" !   #  0 # "  # " !  !  " !$ ! # "# "   '!

 

I                !    """   # $   %  #&'#(#% !#) )* # *"##+ , - "  ""   *"""    .   /!0    !1   2! "1  / 1   #



I     !"#$ %& '(&)*&+%&,-.-/*-.012(&,3/*&4 5**-6/7. ~ 89:;/ -!9

<= ~ 2/*>- 6.!(&:-*-.! 9?&,-.-/* @&.,-*%.!(&:-*-.! 9?&,-.-/* AB<C  DEFG D H DDG FFI D<J=FG D HBFKGL H<  DBHFG D HDHCHM NDOHO

P&Q-.+!-R&S7!(/ -!9>/ !(&?&,-.-/*0 CJ=HECFDD DGG G H  TF G H K T G H  TH G H K O

 !U#V-Q*!7 &.  C AH DDE HBW< 

 C Z[H\ Signature of Member

 C  G<F[L=  Signature of Member

 

XNH<XE  Y  

XNH<XE    b

XNH<XE    Y



 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.