Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction

Decision Information

Decision Content

 !"#$%&'(')*+*,% -..%/ 012345467724581947458:6;<634=>67872?6>8:@238467A81 947458:B36754284672345467282C58DEA81=345467BEF14316>281 GHHIJKLMNOP58;63Q2825186F73;681462;6<8869: 47354>ER38;68167816;6>S

0178P582818686786;TEDSD72F5C782TEDSD4781 =345467S

01947458:284728188178F5768784828672248467TS518 6F73;68167816>358178122:34>281 R45186F73;68186781S

01781528186;81=34546781827421472248467TS5 86;1456>5186F73784878S

 !$#U%/%V*!W%X'(/!')* Y6:7872554587338A8138B5384675ZEEZ[AZBEZ[ABEZDAZBEABEAZBEABE ABE72A[B

Y6:78725545873@C8467A81@C8467B5384675\SAZBE\SABE\SABE\SABE 72]ZAZBABE72<3125384675ABE\AZBE\AB72\AB

_̂%/%X'(/!')*'('*!_%-..%*,'̀!!_%%*,)a!_'(,%&'(')*b

  

 !"#$%&& '()*+!, -./01223411/0351/4322120/46 44371/8030.941213/:0./01/101;41<70.533=1/82.03=/4253 4.3/0.0=/>0/7?;65050.<1=:0.?1/120; 701/70.00./0=2/0107030.@12.0/51035ABC6 3/0.:/70.1/1013/0.;3/02=037273/44013/:220301/ 0.941213//721D73=E

FGHIJ K(I!L

M&(%I!NIO!OG'PH+HOQHJ R(!GM&(%I!()!LH MJS%,!&HI!

>0 ABC6 A6 T403 ABC6 A6 3< ABC6 A6 94 ACU6 AVC6 W/; AV6 ABC6 X; ABC6 A6 ?4. ABC6 A6 1 ABC6 A6 ?; ABC6 A6 R(!G YZ[\]̂_]̀ Y\[]̂]_̂a -./03<1770.?1/120;=10.83/0351/53013/13030.941213/6 -.</0<17/40.?1/120;.7=./1070.941213/1/477E

b0=380530./0030.?1/120;:707820V:c0.820 Vd0e:1/=.14.:51/8030.A:U6U3/0:0./02;2.12f1/8 ghijhklmnogpqhrosktuhgpltosvjwwxhyhslhijpxlolzhghujrhukzhxlhgpyojsl{on A227122/02|}psulzplzhm=2/<7<12735c0.@120/435e ~43/217013/>/0/012571243<;35103/820U:m6-.820V d0232;2:m218/753~BB€31203~;1204.7|}psulzplzhpslk mlztkyplhgpu‚ojgshuƒhshgpx„ztxhlzhcwwhxpsl…ke3;/02002121//7/4; †hnoghlzh‡huhgpxˆojglon‰wwhpx{|Š

  



 !"#$%#&'(')%$)!*+,$-')'.##(#)'&/$(&-'. /$&.0')('")$)!0('(#)-$(&-$'(##('"&$'#(.)($' #')1'.2

$'34567898:;<=>?<@;8;A6BCD<?@8:6E?F634=G696>8;HI8A6JK48;895 F6L?9:8B6<4;8?9MJ3364AN6L8:8?9OPQ64<895>?<@9R@Q6<SFTUVUW;I6SFTUVUX?<@YZ EI6SFTUVUX?<@I4:Q669L?@3A6;6BP89B8L4;895;I6J336A49;C&['$\."]#̂&() $%)!#$%_2̀à$b(..)$])!')̂-)!0('(#)-OP49B:8596B89 "')-)!')$'"#)c2a

..()($',b(.'&%)d&$'#(.)($' e9;I6J336A49;f:'$)(&$%g EI6J336A49;K<?;6C*-)!)!$()(#%'&.(')!)&!.&$b('")2)!(# &$'&.#-#(##($'#)$)!0('(#)-$)! ('$$)!b'(')!(#) '.('"%('.)(')($'$%-$-')#))#('h.+$)$%iOj

 !')#(.!.(#".\()!)!k&(#($'&#!(#b!(&l(%(.##!) C'.])!*+,$-')'.##(#)'&/$(&-'./$&.0'̂O>?<;I636<8?B %$m))$0-('&#(bC\!')!#!)$)($'\#.&.%$ _no)$_nopO1'.2

 !').%'&)$')&!.)('\!(&!'C6q;69:8?9?>;8@649B #)-](#̂#$"!)aO

r'"#)co22)!')$b(..)!,$-')'.##(#)'& (' ])! ('̂\()!..()($'('%$)($'])!h(#)m(##($'̂a !h(#)m(##($'('&.# )!%$$\('"'\('%$)($'b'))$!(#g

'(##"%$)!'))$)! ('2.)."#)co2])!"#) co,(̂2('\!(&!)!')#-#g

sr'"#)cc2)!0('(#)-3<?t8B6BI8@K8;I4C#')O;?;4A895uTPvwvZwx C?>;I6898;84A45<66BR3?9uTPVwvZwxPi<6BRL6B:I6A;6<4@?R9;ZOEI6')#$ %#)$0('(#)-%$CydcO1

sS68:C('z'&)(b-$.('"-')$%)!('('"_&[$\.#!)$') ($)$&$'&('"#'))($'#(')!(#){)$$)&)+!)("!)#)$%( !('"Oj'.

sy\')#C#)-$%$&.('"#')(]!(#̂|}~(()-)$[#'))($'#('% +!)$)&).&$'.()($'#(#('#)).-('z'&)(b(%OZEI6J336A49;4A:? [#%'&)$$)!)#$%.(#)\()!)!0('(#)-a

F654<B895;I6C#')O3<?t8B6BQ=)!0('(#)-$'"#)cc2'.%.)$(')! J336A49;f:X8<:;RQ@8::8?9W;I6F6L?9:8B6<4;8?9R33A6@69;YP6L;8?9€x?>;I6F65RA4;8?9

  



 !"!#$%&'(')#*+,-+.*/0'1%-2%3/()'1%*-#'/(45..6%,%(#'(#$%7..%6-(#8) 9:9!;9<=9!:>;?@A@BAB>C!"DE!:>; !"!D9>;:F!:>;=;!:;>! <

G"H:!=::>;>C!>#$%7..%6-(#8)I:C>E"!>;AB>!:>;C>!" =J>!>CJ;FK:;!!:;EA":LMC KA:;9F:;EBF:9;FF;! A;C:!BNO

P;E!KK!";!>Q:FF!"G:;FF:!:>;:;C>!:>;A!"=9>;F =::>;B<G"=9>;F=::>;C!>;>!"!>CF:!!R;!";! ;F!"S:;:! <G">!"!:F9:F !";!T!C> ;!>C I;!:!:;!">;!>CUKV<C>:!>":"!AQ;BNO

RWQ:F;9X;!F!!"Y:;E Z>!"!";!;F!"S:;:! !;FF!"":;E< !!"":;EK!"7..%6-(#-)[%1\/*-I! >C>9F:;ENO]$%-(%6%_.6-'(%1#$-#!" G:;F:F;>!"Q!"::! !>E;!! >C>9F:;EK!!"!!";!9>FC>;Fa>;;!<G"X;b:;F!>!";!!"!:!R>F;F!>"":>;C>T::;E;Fa>;;!K;F!";9>FF!:;R"!";Fa>;;!R>F T:FF>;G:;>:9 <G$%]*'c5(-68)./6'3+\/*d*-(#'(d-1e/5*(,%(#)*%f5%)#%1-# ":;E ;Fa>;;!9;E;!F !"X;!>:!;FT!":;E!> "F<G";!F9:;F!>̀;Fa>;;!K;F:F!"!"R;>!F!> R" "!">E"!!"g9::>;R;>;KFF:;EIh9!C b9: :E"!;>!!> ̀C!"::>;<N

2%\%**'(d#/#$%7..%6-(#8)*%f5%)#\/*-*%3/0%*+/\#$%3/)#/\*%.-'*)#/$'))$%6#%*i-))!>! '(#$%4%3/(145c,'))'/(i#$%-(%6-)[%1#$%&'(')#*+'\#$-#*%f5%)#j-).-*#/\#$%&'(')#*+8) g9::>;KR":9"R!"a9!>C!"<G"S:;:! :F!"!:!R!T!  !";!C>9::;!K!"!S:;:! F9::>;>;!"T!C>:R:;>9!C:;F9::>;"F;>! !;FK;F;!:>;FR"!9!>C!"! T!R!:;FQ:R<

7)#$%7..%6-(#j-)(/#.*%.-*%1#/)-+j$+$%#$/5d$##$%&'(')#*+8)1%3')'/(j-) ;>;K!"X;9>;9FF!">!>C!"":;E;Fb9F!";!;F !"S:;:! <G"X;:F>;!"R:!;Q:F;99>;!:;F:;!"F>9;!K :;9F:;E!"!R>;!::>;K!>̀:!F9::>;O]$%-(%68)1%3')'/(')!>! >R<

F::::! >CFF:!:>;WQ:F;9 =9!:>;AB>C!"9! !"!;9;9>;:FQ:F;9!"!:;>!!>C!"9>F R";!"S:;:! F:!F9::>;<Z!C:!!";!9>;:F:C!";R:;C>!:>;:

  



 !!"!#$%&'&" ()* $!& '!#! + ,&$ %% $&!$-&!'! $%&$&*!#$%&'&" ,''" %" '&$& .!# ,& *"!&" (

" ,& *"!&" &'& %$$/012345536701890:1/;3:<755376( ,& *"!&" & !#=&'!>&''&" %" % '%"!%!&" !& .!"!#553670189 '+ $ *&!'(

,& *"!&" & %$$& !#>%" $>&''&"  $' !$!!##& .!$!"!# 4553670189?3@A391<:?79A5563B3011:;:C3?123;:91:<?357/?91:2/9#&%-,#&%#&' %" '&$$+!#D& &'!+!"#&'$,& .*"!#"'"*$!& & .#&''#! ", %" !(

E3F/0<:?B71/:05?393013G71123237?/0HF79123I/0/91?J89G39;?/51/:0:<1239171A9:</19 ?3C/3F:<1234553670189?3@A3911:K3?3/BKA?93G<:?123;:919799:;/713GF/12123?357/?:<2/9 $,& .(

>%!&" L"*!#%!'+'!#!& %"''&'! %& %$''#!", %( >%!&" LMNLO"*!#%!'+'%& !'P& . & %'& !#" !"*& %"''&'! % !#+%&$% 'P!#D& &'!+!"%" '&$&!'& &!&$%&'&" ,# !#Q'!$" !&' $%$!" " !,#&%#&'''!# !#R&" !&!$()*-*! %" '&$!&" -!#%& !&'$&''!&'*&$,&!#!#"!%"-!#%& !+!#$%&'&" !" !#S& (>%!&" NO"*!#%!'+'!#!S&  '!%" $%!#& .& !"!# $%&'&" & .$(

>%!&" NLO"*!#%!'+'!#!*!#"$& .#& .!# '!$!& ,#!#!# $%&'&" & .$&''" +'"!$+!#&$ %-"'" &%!&" "* !#%!& !# !8'%&%'! %'(

S#T $"' "!$&!!# ,&$ %& !#=&'!>&''&" -!#>%" $>&''&" -" !#& *"!&" ' !$+!#D& &'!+!!##& .%' " "*&!!'!"!# $%&'&" & .$(''!"!& !#U%&'&"  $''&V$"-!#$%&'&" & .$&'!#D& &'!+89$%&'&" !#!!# !,' "! !&!$!" $$&!&"  W(& '#!", %*"!#" !#"(

  



 !"#$%&'(&)' (%*+%,-&-'( ./01223045677068129/0:/0;:/0<1512:;=>2?0@12145:/6:ABCADECFACAGAHAFC HHGAGFCIJEBAFDCKLFABFCABFMDEEFCNEFAH O=:/00P1?05@04;6;062456O8015:0;7;0:6:1454Q:/0;080P65:80R1286:14515:/0S770865:>2 KGKEACKEJ

S770865:>2T421:145 UBS770865:>27421:1451EABABVGEEANFLFKHGCWEGCAGFCAFBGEFLAB XKGEGFCJUBCAKFCEGHEABIYZJZBKGMHLFAB[GCGEANFCWEA\\Y AFIJEEABC]ABGCGAGWHFC2/08:0;6_4CÀabCHHGAGFCYBDGCFA EcLFBGCW6?d43;5_05:4;0e786159/=/0:/15f2:/0g0@121451235;062456O80h62/0]GE CFAHAFcCNLABEGEEGFCÈa

<1512:;=>2T421:145 ./0<1512:;=>27421:14512ABAABCAGECAGAHAFABiGFCABNEBAFCA LFABGFHKFMHNABXKGEGFCjkAABFWB[NlYAABAFA FCAFMABAAGGFHGEIJEEABCABIYZJZAB[GCGEANFMGHHAFAB CAEKFCEGHAGFCECAJ./0<1512:;=>27421:14512:/6::/0mnhopqapr GCKHECHHGAGFCIJLFFMYCHAB[GCGEANBHHNFMGHHAB CADGABABiGEBAFDCKLFABAFCABJ

sCXKGEGFC KKFHGCWAFABXKGEGFCYFCHAGHMGDFLBGELGYAB[GCGEANHAGCHABAAB S770865:>2P0/1@809438?t3681Q=622/08:0;62?0Q150?15:/080R1286:145aEEAFL ;0@4R51u15R:/0S770865:>2P0/1@80626?90815Rh:/0<1512:;=?0:0;_150?:/6::/0S770865:>E KAFCABNGWGEBAKFEAEIvwJLFBFCCHIJLFLAFBABGE MBGKYLFAFAFLIvwJFCABADCkACH[NJ

UFHAGCABFCAFLKcHAHEBAFDCKAFDBGKBABCADECAGAHY AB[GCGEANHHKAHABFCAFLEBAFDCKMGFENFMGHHAFABCAGC KBFCABADCkACH[NJ

xFCKFCEGHAGFCYCHELKAHGCABXKGEGFCYAB[GCGEANFMH:/0S770865:>2 VEALFKcHAHEBAFDCKHyEACALFABGFHFLkAAF[N FLIYZJZYDBGKBHGHCFAGCKHCNKcHAHFCALFFMJ FMDECFAGCKHHGCABKcHAHFDCKKKAGFCKEAB[GCGEAN HAGCHABCABHMGFENKGMHIvwJLFABAFCABYDBGKBGEAB iGFCAMGAFBGJ

./0T6508;0P1090?:/0<1512:;=>2@68@386:1454Q:/0S770865:>2081R1O80FCABNiG EBAFCAJxFCMGDYABsCLGCHEABAAB[GCGEANEFCNHAGCHABAAB

  

 !"#$%&#%""#$!&!"!%" ' ()*+#%"!, $!&! "!#%"!-#%".#.-%"&# %'#% #%, "#"% &"#%/0#."!1'"#%+

2!3%."!%#" "!""!%"! %#"#455%-45%&"# !#$"!"!55 %#"&4"! !"#$%&.#"!#%"!#.#4,%5! %#" 5 "5"!67879:;<=9>?@>A@?:7B89B;#%" #455.#%-#."!#"!#%"! %#"5% "!C& #%+D 5#%"! "#%"!""!#%" %"!C& #%&#&"- ""5, :EFG?8F@H78I9:E?::EF67879:;<=9>?@>A@?:7B89?;F?>>A;?:FJK%"!"  ,"!3%.%5 "!" "!"#"#%"#.&L5"5 !"#$%&#$%'"#"!%" (,M+M, >?@>A@?:FIN<:EF67879:;<O?8I:EFPQQF@?8:=9;FRAF9:HB;%55"#%( %#" #%- #"5-"!45%&+

SFT?;I78T:EFPQQF@?8:=9PATA9:UVOWXWY;FRAF9:HB;?>;79799AQQ@FZF8::B>B[F;:EF>B9:BH  "#! 5$%',"!3%%#" "!""!%"$#5"# L"!\% "-"# &#% 5%-5& #%"#5%-%-#"#%#.! ] "+##$%'&#% 5"#% 5& #%,"!%"- #!4"!#"#%#.%'"!&#% 5"#%5& #%"# "!2%+

_̀abcdef̀a gEFG?8F@H78I9:E?::EF67879:;<=9hF>797B8OiE7>E5"%5"!""!%"$ %#" %""5"#%55"#%( !"#$%&.#"!#%"!#4,$  #%- #"5-"!45%&%5$  #%%"""#%#."!' "#%%"! PQQF@?8:=9>7;>AZ9:?8>F9+

2!C& #% &#%.5?8I:EFPQQF@?8:=9?QQF?@79%#" && .+

  

$-./010/.2.34-56789:;<=>?;@



 !"#$%

!& '()&!"*"#++$+*",!,*

AB3-C4D/2EE3E.2-C/B:>:F:;GF><;AFH=II:I>?;=F:J=:?F >>=>;:?:I>:;>KA

$-C4D/2EE3E.2-C/2-LEM11N/D/-.E OPQ?;;F;<R;=F:>S;<=:=>;TFH=I=:?F>>=>;:?F>:;;FF GFG=T:=;;<;=>=R=GF=;U

V/C4-E3L/02.34-2-L211/2N03WX.E 5Y678A>F:TZ>;;<=:=>;;F?F:>=IA@ 6?8I?=>=F:;<;>;>=:I?;=F:FG=:?F>>=>;:?AFH=II;FFGF >FF:=:;<>F:[>G=T:=;A\ 68>F:]<F=>I=>>;=>G=I]=;<;<F;?FFGZ>;GF?F:>=I;=F::I >>?;=F:67868;F6I8T;<I?=>=F:;<;=>;<F;?FFG;<Z>;;F;< ;=:U

!D1N4̂D/-.2-LEE3E.2-C/11/2N*03_M-2N 5̀678a<bFT:;:I>>=>;:?a=:=>>;=><I;FI;=:>FG I?=>=F:>;<;:I 68>?;=F:7c68J?F:>=I;=F::I=R<;>KFG;<=>?;A

2-/NE4d.X/.03_M-2N.4C4-LMC.211/2NE ee68:>;?F:I?;<=:R=:;F;<I?=>=F:=:RI]=;<=:;<>?=I fghijkA

#/C3E34-4d12-/N eO678G;<FI=:R;<<=:RZ=I:I>?;=F:68J:>FG;<;=:;F?F:I?; >KS;<:>;I;=:]<;<;<I?=>=F:=:RI=>S>=?S 68>F:T>F;IT;<H=I:?SF

  



 !"#$%#!"!&%'#$"$%"%#"%'$#$ %"$ !&%'  !"#"(%')$# #!"* +!)$# #!"&)%!#"  $%#!",-%'" % $!"&#%')$# #!"#&%'"&#") %'%%')$# #!"#"()#  !". !%).%'/#)"$!#  !"#$%#!"!&%'#$"$%"%#" %'$#$ %"$ !&%' !"#"(%')$# #!"-") !%'0# - $#")%')$# #!"-")#&%')$# #!"!&%'%#"$""!% #"%)0#%'!%&%')$# #!" %!!"%-&%'&%')$# #!"$1%! %'#"# %2 3'%#"' 4$ #/5# )#$%#!"%!#"6##"%!-'"))%#"%'! % ")6 %#!" !&&$%-0"))# $%#!"# #"(!6#)%!)%#")#"" ") $%#!",7")%!1".!)#%)%!)* 8)$# #!"!!)!&%'%#"")%'# $%!"%#" $%!&0'#$'%' %#"' 4$ #/5# )#$%#!"# &#"")$!"$ #/")# "!%!"%!6 %#!"!/#0#" ".$!%*

9:;<=>:9?@A?BACCDC@A?E9F9GH<A@D=?

FIJKLMNOIPQRNKLKPQSSIQTMUSSTIVILR WXYX,+!%'!  !&%'# $%#!"-$!" #)%#!"!# )%#")0'" )$# #!"!&%'#"# %!)$# #!"!&%'%#"' ")#"%' $!" #)%#!"!-#&%')$# #!"$"#"%)0#%'!%&%')$# #!"  %!!"%2 3'#"# %.!/#) "%%!!&!&#."#%%'%# #(#&!#"$!  # %"$2#&$##"%#"%'&#."#%)#/ 6 %&!$!" #)%#!"2#" $% !&)$# #!"%'%- #"%'$ !&&#."#%%'%# #(#&!#"$! # %"$- %)#" )# $!"%#"%#!"!)$%#!"!&#"$! # %"$! "%2

%!".#&%'$##"%( #"0#%#"(%!.%'!"%!&%' "%!/#)) ")%'# $%#!"*  "%")%'# $%#!".!/#))&!%' '!%!& %'#!)%0"%')%%'%6 %&!$!" #)%#!"!"&!# )#/)! #%)")%')%%'%%'$!" #)%#!"!# )%#")-")

  



 !"#$ %& !$  ! !"&'#(("( &'#(& %($'$ #$"('#& "&$&$ !$  ! !'#&("$ "#&#"($ "&$) (& &$ !"((' "#&"("" $ # !*##%"&+#& (,("'-."* !/( *#'#&("$ "#&# !*#"("&(' #*$'"("#& ! ( $"&$' "#&#*"&'#(("( &'#(& , !#& 0%!"'! !"&'#(("( &'#(& %($'$.

12345467589:8;:<768=2:>>2:?2@ ABCD!*##%"&+' +#"(#*(& (&#  # ! "&-.'#&("$ "#&.(& (&$(' "#&E)F

G392@H?2I J736;2I55458:732K:825

L6789?<592?82M:?6N:732 OD!#& !0(! #%&'*#*"0&" # ! !&*"0&" $('"$"&(' "#& CE)C#* !' "( !+ #*  !"&"( # "& !*##%"&+ *# !*"0&" ,&$  !((#* " !*"0&" P(' (! '#( (,&$ " !Q"( # "& !*##%"&+ *# !*"0&" ) J82; R6?H;7B R6?H;7VR6?H;7W S:;4?<T748G4U2L474;H;L:X4;H;

C C(#& YZE YZE

[6N:38H:?592?82M36585:M23:?3H?:82@ \C]# !#(#* !"((' "#&, "" 0'#( (*#*"0&" P('#*("$&'"&'$ #&0 !*##%"&+'#( (- **#! "&+F **#'##̂"&+(F '% F $!0$#F ++$"(#(#_"$$0'#&0#&+%̂0#"%̂0("(F *& #*#&("'("$& "("&+"& !#&)

  



 !"##$%"&$!#$'"$!()!$#')$)'**%("%$+'"($!*'',%"& %$)%"#--. "$*'$!*%("%$/)#'*)%-"#0 '$&&("$)'"$!*%("%$/)#'*)%-"#+%*',"-()'"%" $!*%("%$0 #!')%")"#%*'$!*%("%$/)#'*)%-"#%*',"-( )'"%"$!*%("%$1 $%%$(#')$)0 *$!#$#')$'*%"$""#"-%)*'$!*%("%$/)#'*)%-"#%* ',"-()'"%"$!*%("%$"-%*$!)#')$)!2#%2-$!%"%)$/)%' '23 4*$%%$(#')$)*#$$+$!((2&-'2$!%'-) &%""%"&'"5#$'6"-"-%"&'"7#!6+"- &%""%"&'"%6"-"-%"&'"8$1

  



    !"#$%!&'! ()'* +',&'-./.0+./123)'-40+'5 6+ +.708/ 9:; <0!.":

=> 30+?.!7/")';.+./"!:@'-./.0+ A'/-.+&/")';.+./"!:@'-./.0+ BC=D  EFGH E I EEH GGJ E=K>GH E ICGLHM I=  ECIGH E IEIDIN OEPIP

Q'R./, ".S'T8")0!.":?0!")'@'-./.0+1 DK>IFDGEE EHH H I  UI H I L U H I  UI H I L P

 !"V$W.R+ "8!'/  D DIX>YE ICX= 

 D \>Y> ICDL

 D Z] GG>D

 

C L

ZOI=ZF   [ 

ZOI=ZF   [ 

ZOI=ZF   [ 



 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.