Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction



  

!"#"$%&%'()(#"*+,,"+-%&.!"*"$'(&%#"*+.%'(#"$%&%'(/#+."#0+12/ .!" 3456789:;5<=>:78?56:9:78@A/'B.!"0%(%&.*1'BC'$%+-D"E"-',F"(.+(#G'E"*.1H"#)$.%'(.!" 3I:8:9><J@AKL(.!"H"$'(&%#"*+.%'(D"$%&%'(/.!"0%(%&.*1!"-#.!+..!",,"-+(.M+&('."-%N%O-" B'*+*",-+$"F"(.$!"P)"B'*!%&0+1 #%&+O%-%.1+&&%&.+($"+&.!"$!"P)"/#+."#,*%- Q/  R>S53TS5UV5@A/#"-%E"*"#O1.!"0%(%&.*1B'*0+1+&&%&.+($"!+#O""("(#'*&"#K

C"$.%'('B.!"F,-'1F"(.+(#&&%&.+($"B'*G"*&'(&M%.!D%&+O%-%.%"&H"N)-+.%'( R3WXYZ?4@A[5<\:>9>S5I:8:9><J/%B&,"$%B%$$*%."*%+!+E"O""(F"./.'%&&)"+*",-+$"F"(. 6S5UV5]S5<5=<56:[:58>̂9V858;7<95;6!"P)"!+&O""(-'&.'*&.'-"(K

_ ̀ab 

GcDH &"$.%'(

B)-."d.'B.!"+,,-%$+O-"-"N%&-+.%E",*'E%&%'($+(O"B')(#+..!""(#'BG+*.e'B.!%& #"$%&%'(K

 





  

 !"#$%&"&'!()% %#$'*+%&",%!%$-"&&%&$"#).

%#*'(/"$%'#,*'($0%#%&$(-"$$$%/'*$1)'#&%+("$%'#2)%&%'#%#)!3++$*'!'4%#56

7)' -'*$*('#$"#+,")8'*$9:3;<=>?>?@ABB@CDE>FG=E=>=DCG'#$#+'(&/#$!%#'#$,")8'*$9:3H 7 @CDE>FGIJE>?CKL@BJL>;MD>@MNO>JP@LQR;QSQQ;G=TE@MPK>?@ABB@CDE>=ED /"##($"$4"&)'#&%&$#$4%$$DBB@DLDEO@JU>?@ABB@CDE>FG%#%$%"!&"&$-" "(+'#$("('*$9:3H 7(!"&'* (&'#"!%#*'(/"$%'#*'(/*('/$0%#%&$(-V+"$+ (%! WV V (/%$%#5 $0%#%&$(-$'(!"&%#*'(/"$%'#$'"#'# ('*%$&')%$-V4%)4"&"!&'&%5#+,-$ !"#$%#"/"##()'#&%&$#$<=>?>?@DBB@DLDEO@JU>?@ABB@CDE>FG=E=>=DCGDG>?@K " "(+'#$("('*$9:3H"#+ 7BB@CDE>FGX@YZ@G>UJLX@OJEG=M@LD>=JE[\X]X̂_V4%)4"&+"$+3# V ,3$ " "(&$'"a,#&3,/%$+'#0"- V V%#4%)$ !"#$&$"$+$"$"+()%a+'#!-$():3&%#*'3(/'#$&.

b#$c'$%)'* "!V$ !"#$G>D>@M>?D>\O?@YZ@MDKODI@DEMdM=MEF>T@>DO?@YZ@ê  !"#$*3($(&$"$+$"$+%+#'$8#'4%*%$4"&*'("#3"(-'( (%!"&'#!-"+ &$3,&*'(f,(3"(-"#+0"().

 !"#$4"&#'$ (&#$"$$"(%#5"#+V"*$()'#*%(/%#5$"$$ !"#$"+,# +!%a(+$c'$%)'*g"(%#5%#(& )$'*$%&" "!"!/'&$$4'48& (%'($'$"(%#5 +"$V$"(%#5 (')++%#$",&#)'*$ !"#$V%#"))'(+"#)4%$&)$%'#h.'* $(%,3#"!i(")$%)&"#+i(')+3(&.

$$"(%#5V$0%#%&$(-&$"$+$"$'# (%!hV V$ !"#$"+(:3&$+" ( !")/#$):3.*$((a%4%#5$b#$("))8 (%#$'3$")' -'*,'$$*('#$"#+,")8 '*")"&+):3'*$9:3V$0%#%&$(-+$(/%#+$"$$ABB@CDE>FG):3"+ P@@E@EMJLG@M<=>?DG=TED>ZL@G=I=CDL>J>?@ABB@CDE>FGV4#)'/ "(+$''$(+')3/#$& &%5#+,-$ !"#$.

0%#%&$(-( (&#$"$%a&$"$+$"$&)$%'#'*$ij214"&" !%)",!$'$ABB@CDE>FGO=LOZIG>DEO@GDEM;=E>?=GODG@V"*$()'/ "(%#5$/"(8%#5&'#$#+'(&/#$ !%#'*$9:3$''$(+')3/#$&&%5#+,-$ !"#$V$0%#%&$(-+$(/%#+$"$ $ !"#$"+V%#*")$V#+'(&+$9:3V/"8%#5%/%#!%5%,!*'("( !")/#$ ):3.

 

   

 !   "#$ %!&

 



  

 !""

#$%&&'$%()#%&*++$*,%&-#$)#$.)#$/%(%&).0.$*&1(*2,03$)$.4%($3)#*))#$++$,*()-*& (1)$,%5%2,$61.*.$+,*7$4$()7#$8'$61.#%&/*0 3%&*2%,%)0*&&%&)*(7$*&)#$9#$8'$: -#%7#-*&%&&'$361.;<=>??=@AB;CD/*0*&&%&)*(7$:#*32$$($(31.&$3E



F$7)%1(16)#$GHIJ*')#1.%K$&)#$/%(%&).0)1.$+,*7$1(,0*('($(31.&$3*&&%&)*(7$ 7#$8'$-#$.$AL=MN?N=B;CD*&&%&)*(7$7#$8'$%&$%)#$.,1&)1.&)1,$(E

O(*,%(&)*(7$&-#$.$*7#$8'$#*&2$$($%)#$.,1&)1.&)1,$(:*.$7%+%$()4'&)P

Q/*R$*3$7,*.*)%1(16)#$6*7)&)#*),$3)1)#$7#$8'$51%(54%&&%(5S*(3 QT%U$*('(3$.)*R%(5)1)#$/%(%&).0)1.$)'.()#$,1&)1.&)1,$(7#$8'$:%6.$71U$.$3E

O(*33%)%1()1)#$*21U$.$8'%.$4$()&:-#$.$*7#$8'$%&&)1,$(:*.$7%+%$()4'&)*,&1.$+1.))#$ )#$6))1)#$+1,%7$E

O()#$7*&$16)#$++$,*():)#$/%(%&).012)*%($3)#$O().*7#$7R+.%()1')61.)#$9#$8'$*(3 12&$.U$3)#*)%)#*32$$($(31.&$3:-#%7#+.$7,'3$&)#$/%(%&).06.14.$+,*7%(5%):+'.&'*())1 &$7)%1(16)#$GHIJE

#$/%(%&).0:#1-$U$.:-$()6'.)#$.*(3714+*.$3)#$&%5(*)'.$1()#$$(31.&$4$(),%($16)#$ V<=WX=;YY;<=L=ZA[?@=DY\;<=>??=@AB;CDDN]BA;XL=)1&*)%&60%)&$,6)#*))#$7#$8'$#*3:%( 6*7):2$$($(31.&$320)#$++$,*()E<==ZA[?@=DY\;<=>??=@AB;CDDN]BA;XL=L=_N=̀=abc;<= /%(%&).0*++$*.U$.0&%4%,*.)1)#$&%5(*)'.$1()#$$(31.&$4$(),%($16)#$9#$8'$EO(*33%)%1( )1)#$*21U$ (1)$3&*4+,$&:)#$++$,*()*,&1&%5($3)#$JdJ%(*4*(($.)#*)-*&71(&%&)$() -%)#)#$%(%)%*,&1()#$2*7R16)#$9#$8'$E&&'7#:)#$+*($,6%(3&)#*)%)-*&.$*&1(*2,$61. )#$/%(%&).0)171(7,'3$)#*)%)-*&)#$++$,*()-#1#*3$(31.&$3)#$9#$8'$E

O(U%$-16)#$6*7))#*))#$9#$8'$-*&$(31.&$3*(35%U$()#$?AB=@CD\NBaNB];<A;;<=eNBND;Lc .$*&1(*2,071(7,'3$3)#*))#$++$,*()#*3$(31.&$3)#$9#$8'$:)#$+*($,6%(3&)#*))#$ /%(%&).0.$*&1(*2,03$)$.4%($3)#*)%)3%3(1)#*U$)#$*')#1.%)0)1%&&'$*.$+,*7$4$()7#$8'$ )1)#$++$,*()61.)#$,1&)9#$8'$E

#$++$,*()%&(1)&'77$&&6',%()#%&*++$*,E

 

56



  

 !"#$%& '()*+,(-(./01*02/032/0*(.+2242/+.,(,5(67( 889:;<=>;:>?@=A<=<BCB?B@DE;?@<;;>;=<BF?FA?GC?A<;H??BID;=DE;=DI?BJ=A?K>B>;=?EK<L>;;C?< E?MI<F?K?B=<;IDBN<;J O<P>B=A?F<;?D:=A?:=J=A?K<==?EA<;H??BE?MDE=?@=DMDI>F?J<B@ OHP>B=A?F<;?D:ID;;DE=A?:=J=A?E?F>M>?B= O>PK<Q?;<@?FI<E<=>DBD:=A?:<F=;J<B@ O>PCB@?E=<Q?;=DMEDKM=IL@?I>R?E=A?ID;=DE;=DI?BFA?GC?=D=A?K>B>;=?E >:>=>;E?FDR?E?@S

 

6

Part G - Order The panel decision is: (Check one)

I 2023--0137

181Unanimous

□ By Majority

The Panel 181Confirms the Ministry Decision □ Rescinds the Ministry Decision If the ministry decision is rescinded, is the panel decision referred back to the Minister for a decision as to amount? Yes□ No□

Legislative Authority for the Decision: Employment and Assistance Act Section 24(1 )(a)� or Section 24(1 )(b) � Section 24(2)(a)� or Section 24(2)(b) □

Part H - Signatures Print Name Adam Shee Signature of Chair

Print Name Edward Wong Signature of Member

Print Name Kim Louie

EMT (2611W22)

Date (Year/Month/Day) 2023/June/5

Date (Year/Month/Day) 2023/06/05

Date (Year/Month/�?) 2-,dL- 3 ( or o S:-

Signature Page