Ministry of Education and Child Care

Decision Information

2024-0071

Collection Ministry of Education and Child Care
Date 2024-04-04
Subjects Overpayment

Decision Content

    !"#"$%&%'()(#"*+,,"+-%&.!"*"$'(&%#"*+.%'(#"$%&%'('/.!"0%(%&.*1'/#)$+.%'(+(#2!%-# 2+*"3456789:;#+."#<+()+*1 =  34567>:;?@AB5@C5456 0%(%&.*1#"."*D%("#.!+..!",,"-+(.E+&('."-%F%G-"/'*.!"/)-#+1$!%-#$+*"&)G&%#1.!+.!" *"$"%H"#/'*.!","*%'#G".E""(I'H"DG"* = +(#J"G*)+*1K= L=*"&)-.%(F%(+( 'H"*,+1D"(.'/M = K NOPN&+*"&)-.=.!",,"-+(.%&-%+G-".'*",+1.!"0%(%&.*1M = K NOPN

> QRS  T 2!%-#2+*"U)G&%#1$.34567:;V&"$.%'(&O=+(# T 2!%-#2+*"U)G&%#1W"F)-+.%'(34567>SX :;V&"$.%'(& +(#L T J%(+($%+-#D%(%&.*+.%'($.V&"$.%'(K

YZ!"/)-."[.'/.!"+,,-%$+G-"-"F%&-+.%'(%&+H+%-+G-"+/."*.!"\"$%&%'(N

 



     !""#$%&'() *+,-./*0 12345-6*+7 8  9 :;<=>?>@AB>A@C>AA@  D,2 -7 3 E5+ F 6,-,0F+4*FF G 75-0,2 +*F,5-H 7,0,5-75-0,0F 25EI J KL#!""#$%&'()M%NO$PQR&)O)')RMLON)#$MSLO))"RT)#S%&U'L#OV'LV##WXYQLO$UV#&9 J Z-H 7 [3 + 8 8F \,12\*+ ] +D,7 \ -F+ Ŵ___̀Y+ 7 ,D 2F !""#$%&'() E5+2*31 \,12\*+ a - E,FŴb__c̀Ydd1,7*F,5-F*F/*00,.- 2*-22*F 234F dd 1*-F *-2,00d5e0 5-f5D [3 + 8 'L#̂bgghAA@̀ 9

J i +F dd1,7*F,5-8F dd 1*-F,-2,7*F 2F*F5-145-  5E,07,12+ -+ je,+ 27,127*+ E+5[kI *9[9F5 I d9[9 dd 1*-F ld1*,- 2F*F *2*[ 2,7*175-2,F,5-/,7d+ D -F 2,[ E+5[ d+5D,2,-.7,127*+ 3 F/ - I *9[9*-2 I d9[9 *72*49 22,F,5-*148F dd 1*-F*2D,0 28/,F0edd5+F,-.257e[ -F08F*F,00d5e0 /*0*F -2,-. 07551865-2*4F5m+,2*4E+5[kI *9[9e-F,1 I d9[9

J 0d*+F5EF dd1,7*F,5-8F dd 1*-F0e3[,F 2*-E5+2*31 \,12\*+ a - E,F\,12\*+ ++*-. [ -FnRVNW'L# ̂ Ỳ9o#V'L#nRVNS'L#!""#$%&'()QLO$Up5e12+ 7 ,D 7,127*+ 65-2*4F5m+,2*48E+5[kI *9[9F5 I d9[9834*1,7 -0 2E*[,147,127*+ d+5D,2 +9

J Z-H 7 [3 + 8 8F \\]\E5e-2F dd 1*-F 1,.,31 E5+F \\a*-2,00e 2* 3 - E,Fd1*-E5+ Ee12*40d +[5-F*FF q,7 -0 2r+5ed\*+ sr+*F E5+F d +,525E f5D [3 + 8 8F5H 7 [3 + 8 9 dd 1*-F/*0*2D,0 2D,*,064m*[,14] +D,7 Ŵt̀Y[ 00*. d5+F*1F*F8,E + je,+ 27,127*+ E5+3 45-2u*-e*+4  8 /5e12- 2 F5d+5D,2 07551+ .,0F+*F,5-E5+,00d5e0 F*F,-71e2 2 +-*[ 8*-2F 0F*+F -22*F 0 5E +75e+0 09

J Z-u*-e*+4v8  8F dd 1*-F0e3[,F 275e+0 ,-E5+[*F,5-E5+,00d5e0 *-2+ je 0F 2 *dd+5D*1E5+75-F,-e 2\\a9w-25,-.058F dd 1*-F75-E,+[ 2F*F,00d5e0 /*0 -+51 2,-Ee+F +75e+0 0E+5[u*-e*+4x8  8F+5e.F5m 3+e*+48  9 75e+0 0 +*-65-2*4F5m+,2*4E+5[xI *9[9e-F,1 I *9[9

J Z-m 3+e*+4 8  8F \\]\E5e-2F dd 1*-F 1,.,31 E5+F \\a*-2,00e 2*3 - E,F d1*-E5+ Ee12*40d +[5-F*FF q,7 -0 2r+5ed\*+ sr+*F E5+F d +,525Eu*-e*+4 8  8F5m 3+e*+4k8  9

J Z-f5D [3 +k8  8F y +,E,7*F,5-*-2e2,FZE,7 +̂zb{̀ 75-71e2 2*+ D, /5EF !""#$%&'()!||}E,1 *-2E5e-2,[,- 1,.,31 E5+~ 8 k 9vx5EF \\aF*F + 7 ,D 2 3 F/ -f5D [3 + 8 8*-2m 3+e*+4k8  W'L#̂{>g>@̀Y9Z-F*F0*[ 2*48 *H 3Ff5F,E,7*F,5-i*7€*. 1 F +/*00 -FF5F dd 1*-F*2D,0,-.,[5EF ZD +d*4[ -F9

J L#!""#$%&'%""$O#U MRV%V#QR&)OU#V%'OR& RM'L#O&O)'VP()U#QO)OR& V#‚%VUO&‚ F ZD +d*4[ -Fƒ„&'L#!""#$%&'()+ je 0FE5++ 75-0,2 +*F,5-8 ld1*,- 2F 3*0,0E5+,0 + je 0FE5+\\a8F*F,07,12+ 7 ,D 23 F/ - 9vF5v5e+05E7,127*+ d +2*4*FF

 

    !"# $% & '(()*+ , -. $$ ($ / / 0 0 1/ 001  0020   "##"$ (##/001 ($ (/#/ (/ /( /%

 

3#" / (4(/$ (5   /002)$(( ( // (  / (  (#($ ( (%

#2  /002$(6/ 6  (/#" ( #"// %1 " / ($" 001/ /( #((/ ( 4( (# 7,5  ,5 # %

825/ ()4(/) (9# ( :;<=:>?::@A<<B:@A>C=B>:DEFD>CEDGHIIEJ EKCL>@E=:><MDA> ((# (($/7,  7,5 %  ( (($(#(#  ,5  ,5 #/(#( /9( % (  $(/4(/ %

002( 002 2 (/ ( #/# ## $"( #%/002 2 0022N 002)$(2 5 / ($"(/ /001/ ("/# O"  P( 7 5%/ (# Q  7 %NR("#%

STUVWUXYZU[ "/"" $( %\(  /##/( ("# (/

      !"#$#$$% $ #$$ $ &'(

)*+,-./00.12 34    56789::8;<=6>?;8@<AB6?C8B>9::8<;D678E/00.12FGHIJ.(K!L$$M#$$%N

E'LO%# &%O&#N !&L&MP ##% Q#& R4%% !

! %$# R# !

S!L&%  $#O$#    !

!L% OT##$& %L%#$L ##&&M P '(

3R# S  $$%! UO $$O%#%&$$M#!3&$$# &##$!

R&$$$V#%#O#& V#U#!L$Q&$$WR N

X %$$%$% &$%# YYZ&&&[

X R$$YYZ&&&[ X 3$9::8;<=6\]&[ X 3$&$&R[ X R#C;<?̂ 678_̀8a:<b̂ 8=6>aB̂ 6789::8;<=6\]C7?;@C<a8:aB̀?@8a<]678  %$$$# &#!

)J+F.cdeIf.gJ.

 

    !"  ## $

% &'()'*+,-.,/,0123445344 678  9  #:;'(<

% !4 =8 >$2?@A'BACA@?DADE*AF34:G <H<(EIEJKALIIEICAMH(HBI*+NB(AOAPH<A(LAJ)I4# !" 6Q899 #49 99  6

RNB#9# 9 44 9  3 99# S43  3439 4 3 9 46T #8R #@HI@AOAHUCIIEICAMH(HBI*+NB(AOAPH<A(LAUHPA(IC'IICAMH(HBI*+<H<(EIB)JDHILE?HAB 3!"  3Q9 V48 #3  R 9 39  9949 3!" 6

 



     !""# #$% &'(( ')!"* & '"+$',) $ ""+-* . /+$"!% &'*!+$0 /!"!+$!$1!/* 2!$!"*&3% * &4!$ %*'** (( )'$*1'"!$ )!5!,) -+&* -#)%'3667*'* & / !8 %-+& * ( &!+%, *1 $9+8 4, & : :'$%; ,&#'&3<: =:& "#)*!$5!$'$>8 &('34 $*+-? : < @AB@

CDDEFGHIJKLMKNINMH  (( )'$*'&5# "*'* "+#)%$+*, )!',) -+&* >8 &('34 $*'"!*& "#)* %-&+4* OPQPRSTUVRWTTXTYZR[TWR\]ŜS_Ẁ aWTb[UcWQSR_X\]deWfX]WfSWdgTXcS_Wb[TSUS_[STWfWPaWdPS h_Pf_̂PQS_PRf[RŴh[RS_WZbbW][QSVRf_P]df[TWbTXaPdWTY

iNHNKIjkJKLMKNINMH  2!$!"*&34'!$*'!$"*'** (( )'$*1'"!$ )!5!,) -+&-#)%'3667VR, $ -!*"& / !8 %-+& * ( &!+%, *1 $9+8 4, & : :'$%; ,&#'&3<: =-+&* & '"+$""*'* %!$* . /+$"!% &'*!+$0 /!"!+$@

 lmnoopqrstuvwxyzvr { /*!+$ +-* /*dWgPQWR[QZ||}̂XT~f_P]df[TWR\eRPdÛ[R[b[UcWQSc[dW\QdWTS_W/* *++&-+&'('& $**+"#,"!%!€ * /+"*"+-/!)%/'& @$+* &1+&%":'$667!"('!%*++&-+&' ('& $*+$)3!-* 3'& $*!*) %*+& / !8 !*@‚#*%!- & $*)3:!-* 2!$!"*&3('3"'$667*+'/!)% /'& (&+8!% &+$, ')-+-'('& $*:!*!"+$)3, /'#" *'*('& $*!" $*!*) %*+& / !8 '$667@ "'& "#)*:* ‚'$ )-!$%"*'** 2!$!"*&3/+#)%+$)3('3'$667*++&-+&* (( )'$*!- 1'" $*!*) %*+& / !8 +$ @

;#&* &:" /*!+$ +-* . 5#)'*!+$dWgPQWR~g\]d[UPQTW][SPXQSXf_P]df[TW[RcXTWS_[Qƒ_X\TR Xgf_P]df[TWbTXaPdWdPQ[d[UY|XQaWTRW]Û[~_[]gd[U!$& )'*!+$*+/!)%/'& 4 '$" +#&"+& ) ""+-/!)%/'& (&+8!% %!$'%'3@$* /'" +-* (( )'$*:,+** (( )'$*'$%* 2!$!"*&3'/„$+1) %5 *'** (( )'$*'(()! %-+&~_[]gd[U6675!8 $*'* & …#!& %/!)% /'& -+& +#&+&) ""( &%'3@"'& "#)*:'$%, /'#" $ !* &('&*3& -#* "S_WZbbW][QSVR )!5!,!)!*3-+&~_[]gd[U667:* ‚'$ )-!$%"*'** 2!$!"*&3& '"+$',)3'(()! %* '(()!/',) ) 5!")'*!+$1 $!*% * &4!$ %*'** (( )'$*1'" $*!*) %*+& / !8 ~_[]gd[U667@

†+1 8 &:* 4'!$!""# !$*!"(( ')!"$+*1 * &* (( )'$*1'" $*!*) %*+& / !8 ~_[]g d[U667‡&'* &:!*!"1 * &* (( )'$*"+#)%,  )%)!',) -+&* OPQPRSTUVR[dcPQPRST[SPaW &&+&1!/"'1!4TWfWPaW~g\]d[U667'$%1!/:#)*!4'* )3:& "#)* %!$* >8 &('34 $*@  ‚'$ )$+* "*'*:(#&"#'$**+" /*!+$ +-* /*:!-'$667!"('!%*++&-+&'( &"+$1+ !"$+* $*!*) %*+!*:*'*( &"+$!")!',) *+& ('3*+* 5+8 &$4 $** '4+#$**+1!/* ( &"+$1'"$+* $*!*) %@$* /'" +-* (( )'$*:* ‚'$ )-!$%"*'** (( )'$*1'"$+* $*!*) %*+~g\]d[UZ||}5!8 $*'* & / !8 %/!)%/'& -+& +#&"+&) ""( &%'3‡'"'& "#)*:  h[RXQ]UWQSPS]WdSXTWfWPaW~_[]gd[UZ||}gXTS_WbWTPXdeWShWWQˆXaWceWT‰̂Š‹ŠŠ̂[Qd

 



       !"#"$$%&"' !('' ) * " +( "# ( (#+," + (" )-*'+

."+ !"'' (-*'+) *$$%(/   01 &"' !( +(& #&"( !

234567896:;8<=>6?96:@A;B6C= (D'')"E  ""(!'" "# !#'(* !( -*'+ !""# ( (#F "E  "('" ''(-*'+) *&"'"( !( ) "# ( ( #GHIJKHLMKNOOPQRSTUVJWGUMSHLXYLJGZ[QMLM\MZ]HK̂]MGHXKGHŜVH#(((' ("" ! _#(""(# !#"$$%#(!(' !(((''( &" !(# *("# ( (#(!" + 

NLĴSHWM̂HL̂R V̂H`JKJL̂SZaLMG]JKJL̂SM̂JbHHSSRSQ #(c) (" ! ''(+* )('-*'+d(&*E  "!'' ('( "(''!# c#(" ! (e# " ((!(" "# (( # !+  " (#'(* !" )(*+","(#(* (*'+(+(' !('"(#((#+'"(+( !#("(''.# #+"#" ''(E  " "!()!  ""("(''f ("(+"+ "" ("( ""("('' " R̂URKLJGHSJIĴM\\WJHLJKV̂HN\\HWMK̂aLUJSUX]L̂MKUHLMLMYMŜRV̂H̀ JKJL̂SZaL#(*( -*'+

("# #+"#"*'')f  "# ( (#+,"'"( ('E  "(""# ( (#'(* !"E  "+ ()+(+##' ) "" )!('+($$%g# ( (#'(* !"E  " + ('+)+& #"))""E  ""! "# (  #(# ("'(#""h *# #+"#"E  " "#()!( !'+'("#!+"!"(''& ##(! #!#' (!  *''!,"("(#(*-*'+(+ "# !#'(* !

i8C7jklm8C nVHoMKHWIJKGL̂VM̂ V̂H̀ JKJL̂SZaLGHUJLJRK!+  )''&"  ) (TIXW GMZ[$$%&p(*+  !  &""('' # (('' #) " ( # #+"#" ( !"'' "  ('-*'+'"("# ( (#

'' "("##""(''

 

     !"#$%&&'#"(' )*+,*" -* %  ./012345678902:/; <"" <=>?@A?B?C=>@D=?E>F@E>GDHIAJDDKKGLKG? B?G>@DDKAFMAIEIN>DH>JKADAKLJHIOEJ?G>P

 

)*+,*" Q  RKGDH>BFGBKA>KLE>D>G=I@I@SKG?FEIDI@S>OISIMIOIDCLKGJHIOEJ?G> AFMAIEI>ATDH>=I@IAD>G=?CEKK@>KG=KG>KLDH>LKOKUI@SV

? EIG>JD?B>GAK@UHKH?A?BBOI>ELKG?JHIOEJ?G>AFMAIECTKGDKKGLKG UHK=?JHIOEJ?G>AFMAIECIAB?IETDKAFBBOCDH>=I@IAD>GUIDH I@LKG=?DIK@UIDHI@DH>DI=>?@EI@DH>=?@@>GAB>JILI>EMCDH> =I@IAD>GP

M A>>WX>GILIJ?DIK@KL?@CI@LKG=?DIK@AFBBOI>EMC?B>GAK@G>L>GG>EDK I@B?G?SG?BH? P

J EIG>JD?B>GAK@G>L>GG>EDKI@B?G?SG?BH? DKAFBBOCX>GILIJ?DIK@KL ?@CI@LKG=?DIK@AFBBOI>EMCDH?DB>GAK@KG?@KDH>GB>GAK@P

E JKO>JDLGK=?B>GAK@I@LKG=?DIK@?MKFD?@KDH>GB>GAK@IL I DH>I@LKG=?DIK@G>O?D>ADKDH>?BBOIJ?DIK@LKGKGB?C=>@DKL? JHIOEJ?G>AFMAIECT?@E

I DH>=I@IAD>GH?A@KDAKOIJID>EDH>I@LKG=?DIK@LGK=DH>B>GAK@ UHKBGKXIE>AIDY

 B>GAK@DKKGLKGUHK=?JHIOEJ?G>AFMAIECIAB?IE=FAD@KDILCDH>=I@IAD>GT UIDHI@DH>DI=>?@EI@DH>=?@@>GAB>JILI>EMCG>SFO?DIK@TKL?@CJH?@S>I@ JIGJF=AD?@J>A?L>JDI@SDH>IG>OISIMIOIDCF@E>GDHIAJDY

Z [L?B>GAK@L?IOADKJK=BOCUIDH?EIG>JDIK@F@E>GAFMA>JDIK@ ? KGJ KGUIDH AFMA>JDIK@ TDH>=I@IAD>G=?C

? E>JO?G>DH>B>GAK@I@>OISIMO>LKG?JHIOEJ?G>AFMAIECF@DIODH>B>GAK@ JK=BOI>ATKG

      !  "#$%&&  ' &(#&  ')!

*+,-./01,2345-,./01,234/26/447821,234   9# #(%  $'&&(( !

K,L72737E24

 :;$%&& $&%&  $$%# &# !

<  &$&& ##  !

 &   $& $'& &

 ' #&;%   #& = #& &  $'&&!

 &&   $&  < !

>?7@6>/-,ABC4760D,8B@/37E25F>D,8GHIJG

M  NOPQRSTUVWXYPRZO[ \LB@6/0\%%&  & #' %  '## ] \?/@L6/0\%%& # ' %'##  ]

 

    !"  #$%&'&()$*%+,-+,+.#&/0.+*$(12(&0,3'/,&4 + )#$%&'&()$*&((+)&(4&$0)#+))#$.#&/0.+*$&('$$0$043*3'$34)#$ *$+(3'(($)31)&'(12($.)&3' 5

2 )#$.#&/0.+*$&(+**+'6$03**$.3%%$'0$01'0$*)#$7#&/058+%&/, +'073%%1'&),9$*:&.$.)53*

. )#$.#&/0.+*$&(*$.3%%$'0$01'0$*)#$73%%1'&),;&:&'6 1)#3*&),.)&'*$(-$.)34+.#&/0<#3#+(+-+*$')+--*3:$043*3* *$.$&:&'6.3%%1'&),/&:&'6(1--3*)1'0$*)#$73%%1'&),;&:&'6 1)#3*&),.)+'0)#$%&'&()$*&((+)&(4&$0)#+))#$.#&/0.+*$&('$$0$0=

 83*)#$-1*-3($34(12($.)&3' + 5)#$.#&/0.+*$%1()2$'$$0$043*3'$34 )#$43/3<&'6*$+(3'(>

+ &'+(&'6/$-+*$')4+%&/,52$.+1($)#$-+*$') & &($%-/3,$03*($/4 $%-/3,$05 & +)$'0(+'$01.+)&3'+/&'()&)1)&3'5 && &(($$?&'6$%-/3,%$')3*-+*)&.&-+)&'6&'+'$%-/3,%$') *$/+)$0-*36*+%53*

&: #+(+%$0&.+/.3'0&)&3')#+)&')$*4$*$(<&)#)#$-+*$')@( +2&/&),)3.+*$43*)#$-+*$')@(.#&/0A

B CDE EFGHIJKKLFJ"M NO  O  ! OD MP  Q4-12/&.%3'$,&(-+&0)3+-$*(3'2,)#$63:$*'%$') + &'$R.$((34)#$+1)#3*&),.3'4$**$02,+'$'+.)%$')5 2 <&)#31))#$+1)#3*&),34+'$'+.)%$')53* . .3')*+*,)3+'$'+.)%$')5 +'0+*&6#)&(+(($*)$02,)#$63:$*'%$'))3*$.3:$*)#$-+,%$')3*-+*)34&)53* )3*$)+&'3)#$*%3'$,&'41/3*-+*)&+/(+)&(4+.)&3'34+./+&%+*&(&'631)34)#$ -+,%$')5)#$-$*(3'+6+&'()<#3%)#$*&6#)&(+(($*)$0%+,5(12S$.))3 (12($.)&3' 5*$/,3'+',%+)$*344+.)3*/+<5&'./10&'6$()3--$/5)#+)<31/0

 



 

    ! !!"#

 $ %%  ! ! !&!!"%&' !!  !!%   !&!!"%&#

 !"#$%&$'($)#$*+,+-(+,./0&$*1-($2



3((+4-5,

6789-+7

:;<=>?<@ 0-(A+4,&$8+(+,7B$*+,+-( C$,*+(#,&$8+(+,7B$*+,+-( DEF;<GH?HIFJKL<MHIHN?HIJ<IMH?L<LOHIF;<P>?<@L<MHIHN?J<E<JJ<LQ>MR FNF;<SH?HIF<JENJ>L<MHIHN?>IFN>GNT?FU V<IW XNY Z$[+,)+\$]5&-+7A-&$B$*+,+-(. ĜP@NKG<?F>?L_IIHIF>?M<_MF <̀MFHN?aba>bY NJ̀<MFHN?abaQbc <̀MFHN?aba>bc NJ̀<MFHN?abaQbY

d!e+[(5$,

=JH?FX>G< _?H@_ff>Jg>@

H̀f?>FTJ<NEh;>HJ

i>F<aV<>JjSN?F;ji>Kb  kl

=JH?FX>G< mnmop

H̀f?>FTJ<NES<GQ<J

i>F<aV<>JjSN?F;ji>Kb  kl

=JH?FX>G< q rs

H̀f?>FTJ<NES<GQ<J

  

i>F<aV<>JjSN?F;ji>Kb  kl



 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.